Eternal Security: Faith Without Works

The New Testament consistently presents good works as the natural evidence of genuine faith. When a person receives the Holy Spirit, their heart is transformed in a way that is both real and often unexpected. New Testament writers regularly look for this inner change—expressed outwardly in a transformed life—as confirmation that someone truly believes.

James, however, poses a difficulty. The letter repeatedly warns its audience of judgment and destruction for failing to produce works. If James is writing only to already-saved Christians, the implications are troubling. It would mean God may ultimately destroy believers who do not produce enough fruit.

James could have simply encouraged greater fruitfulness without threatening destruction. The presence of these threats challenges the idea that God produces all the fruit needed to ensure salvation. Christians could not fully trust the Lord to supply the strength they need. Instead, they would have to strive to make up for what He did not provide, and their salvation would begin to look uncertain.

This tension is resolved, however, when readers accept that James was not written exclusively to Christians. He addressed the Jewish tribes of the diaspora, which included both believers and unbelievers. While the letter contains encouragement for Christian Jews (e.g., James 1:2–5, 9, 12, 16–18; 5:10–11, 19–20), it primarily challenges the unbelief and sinfulness of his unbelieving listeners, some of whom aspired to leadership in local synagogues.

The Twelve Christian Tribes?

Calling the audience “brothers” and addressing “the twelve tribes scattered abroad” does not prove a Christian readership. Peter used “brothers” for unbelieving Jews (Acts 2:29; 3:17; 7:2; 13:26). The “twelve tribes” language lacks the qualifiers typically used when addressing Christians or churches. Instead, it more naturally refers to the historic Jewish diaspora, who continued practicing Judaism and building synagogues, rather than only the believers who fled Saul’s persecution (Deuteronomy 28:64; Leviticus 26:33; 2 Kings 17:5–6; Jeremiah 9:16; Ezekiel 11:16; Luke 21:24).

Warnings Against Unbelief

Many of his warnings do not make sense when directed as born again Christians. James 5:1–6 calls the rich to “weep and howl” for the miseries coming upon them:

James 5:1-6 Come now, you rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming on you. Your riches are corrupted and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and your silver are corroded, and their corrosion will be for a testimony against you and will eat your flesh like fire. You have laid up your treasure in the last days. Behold, the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you have kept back by fraud, cry out; and the cries of those who reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Armies. You have lived in luxury on the earth, and taken your pleasure. You have nourished your hearts as in a day of slaughter. You have condemned and you have murdered the righteous one. He doesn’t resist you.

He urges them to “put away all filthiness and overflowing of wickedness” and to “receive with humility the implanted word, which is able to save your souls” (James 1:21). This shows he was primarily addressing unbelieving Jews who had not yet accepted the gospel.

The bulk of the warnings target those who doubt and are double-minded (James 1:6–8), who must still accept the word in order to be saved (James 1:21), whose “faith” is demonic and without works (James 2:1, 14, 19–20), who bless and curse from the same mouth (James 3:10), who display jealousy, selfish ambition, and demonic wisdom (James 3:13–16), who quarrel, scheme, and even kill (James 4:1–2), who make themselves enemies of God through friendship with the world (James 4:4), who remain double-minded sinners needing to purify their hearts (James 4:7–10), and who risk judgment and condemnation (James 5:9, 12). These are not descriptions of Spirit-sealed saints.

Internal evidence points to Jewish teachers of the law who taught the law rather than faith, condemned believers (James 2:6; 3:1, 10; 4:11–12; 5:6, 9), and possessed useless wisdom, dead works, and a faith that lacked evidence. James warned they would be judged unless they changed course. His exhortation for believers to ask God directly for wisdom (James 1:5) may have empowered Christian Jews to rely on God alone rather than continue sitting under synagogue teachers who persecuted them. If James was written in the early 60s, his prohibitions against cursing and oaths (James 3:10; 5:9, 12) may also target the Birkat haMinim—the synagogue curse against Nazarenes/Christians.¹

James taught that works are the evidence of genuine faith. He was not criticizing true Christians for an insufficient quantity of good deeds. He was exposing Jewish leaders who claimed to have faith yet whose lives proved otherwise—favoritism, oppression, and dead orthodoxy revealed that their profession was empty.

Treating the entire letter as addressed only to believers forces contradictions with the rest of the New Testament. One would have to assume that believers can be called “sinners” with impure hearts (James 4:8), condemned (James 5:12), and judged (James 5:9); that their future sins remain unforgiven (James 5:15); that they can be labeled “enemies of God” and “adulterers” (James 4:4); and that their faith may not be adequate to save them (James 1:21; 2:1, 14, 19–20).

In contrast, Scripture never calls a believer a sinner (Romans 5:8; Titus 3:3; 1 Timothy 1:13–15; Romans 1:7; Ephesians 1:1; 1 Corinthians 6:11)—not even in James itself (James 5:19–20). Believers’ hearts are purified by faith alone (Acts 15:9; Hebrews 10:14; Colossians 2:11–14; Titus 3:5–7). Christians will never be judged or condemned (John 5:24; Romans 8:1). All of a believer’s sins—past, present, and future—are already forgiven (Hebrews 9:26; 10:14, 17–18; Colossians 2:13–14; Ephesians 1:7; 1 Peter 3:18; 1 John 1:7; 2:12). They are friends of God and no longer His enemies (John 15:14–15; Romans 5:10; Colossians 1:21–22).

Scripture does not contradict itself.

Summary

James does not threaten true believers with destruction for lacking enough good works. The letter is mainly written to a mixed Jewish audience that included many unbelievers. Its strong warnings expose empty claims of faith in God—believing that “God is one”—and the lives of those whose “faith” produced no real change.

This removes any conflict with the rest of the New Testament. Scripture never describes genuine believers as enemies of God or people whose salvation depends on producing enough fruit. Good works are the natural result of a heart already changed by the Spirit. God himself produces the evidence of real faith.

Correctly identifying James’ audience allows Christians to rest secure in God’s gift of eternal life.

Footnotes: